The 2021 Buick Enclave and 2021 Toyota Highlander are three-row mid-size SUVs that aim to provide painless family transportation.
Buick Enclave 2021
Above average: Calm; adult-sized third row seat; spacious cargo hold, even with the third seats in use; powerful standard V6 engine.
Below average: Common active safety features are missing from the lower trims; second row bench seat not available.
Consensus: The 2021 Buick Enclave is one of the largest vehicles in its class and offers a comfortable interior and generous luggage space. It offers a quiet ride to go with the premium interior.
Toyota Highlander 2021
Above average: Exceptional fuel economy of the hybrid version; good resale value; many active safety features.
Below average: The third row seat is strictly for children; The hybrid model’s tow rating is only 3,500 pounds.
Consensus: The 2021 Toyota Highlander is a practical choice for a family SUV, with seating for 7 or 8 passengers, a choice between a rugged V6 engine or a highly fuel-efficient hybrid, and a solid reputation for reliability.
Enclave vs Highlander: Spacious SUVs Suitable for Families
Buick strives to be more than a mainstream brand, and this is reflected in Enclave 2021Sophisticated styling inside, muscular 310 horsepower V6 and quiet drive. The generously proportioned Enclave offers plenty of room for passengers, including in the standard third row seat. All Enclaves are equipped with second row captain’s chairs – a bench for three is not offered. With all the seats used, many three-row SUVs have little cargo space, but the Enclave has a generous 23.6 cubic feet. Its maximum cargo capacity of 97.6 cubic feet is also best-in-class. The standard 3.6-liter V6 can tow up to 5,000 pounds, but fuel economy is only average at 21 mpg combined with front-wheel drive and 20 mpg with all-wheel drive. Unfortunately, driving aids such as forward collision warning, automatic emergency braking and lane-keeping assist are not available in the two lower versions, and adaptive cruise control is reserved for the vehicle. ‘High-end future.
the Toyota highlander has been redesigned for 2020 and offers Toyota virtues such as value, fuel economy and reliability. Buyers choose a V6 engine with a generous output of 295 horsepower or a four-cylinder hybrid, now available with front-wheel drive or all-wheel drive. The hybrid isn’t as fast as the V6 (and only tows 3,500 pounds compared to 5,000 for the V6), but its fuel mileage is impressive: 36 mpg combined (FWD) or 35 mpg (AWD). With six trim levels, including a sporty XSE that’s new for 2021, plus four for the Highlander Hybrid, and either captain’s seats or a second-row bench seat, buyers have plenty to choose from. Fortunately, all Highlanders include forward collision warning with automatic emergency braking, adaptive cruise control, lane departure warning and lane keep assist, with blind spot monitoring and rear cross traffic alert from Standard on all except the L base. A pleasant driving experience and a decently spacious interior complete the package.
Three-row mid-size SUVs with standard V6 engines; 5,000 lb maximum towing capacities.
2021 Buick Enclave advantages
A quieter interior; more comfortable third row seat for adults; more cargo space, especially behind the third row seat.
Advantages of the 2021 Toyota Highlander
Lower starting price and more standard driving aids; available hybrid variant with exceptional fuel economy; better mileage with its V6 engine; top notch resale value; long-standing reputation for reliability.
The Enclave offers an added measure of luxury, especially in Avenir form, but its starting price is about $ 5,000 higher and can go up to $ 56,000. Despite the higher price tag, most Enclave trims lack common active safety features that are included on the Highlander. The Toyota also benefits from improved fuel economy and an available hybrid powertrain. The Enclave has more interior space, but unless the Highlander isn’t big enough for your needs, the Toyota is the best value and the best bet.
Ready to buy a Buick Enclave or a Toyota Highlander? Buy now for one on sale near you.
|Buick Enclave 2021||Toyota Highlander 2021|
|Engine||3.6-liter V6||3.5-liter V6|
|Power||310 hp at 6,800 rpm||295 hp @ 6,600 rpm|
|Couple||266 lb-ft @ 2,800 rpm||263 lb-ft @ 4,700 rpm|
|Transmission||9 speed automatic||8 speed automatic|
|Fuel economy||21 mpg (18 city / 26 highway)||24 mpg (21 city / 29 highway)|
|Also available||AWD||2.5L I-4 hybrid; AWD|
|guarantee||3 years / 36,000 miles||3 years / 36,000 miles|
|NHTSA Global Security||5 stars||5 stars|
|Maximum seating capacity||7||8|
|Wheelbase||120.9 inch||112.2 inch|
|Total length||204.3 inch||194.9 inch|
|Width||78.8 inch||76.0 inch|
|Height||69.9 inch||68.1 inch|
|Turning diameter||39.0 feet||36.1 feet|
|Headroom, forward||42.6 inch||39.9 inch|
|Headroom, 2nd row||39.9 inch||39.4 inch|
|Headroom, 3rd row||37.6 inch||36.1 inch|
|Legroom, front||41.2 inch||40.4 inch|
|Legroom, 2nd row||38.9 inch||41.0 inch|
|3rd row legroom||33.5 inch||27.7 inch|
|Shoulder room, front||62.4 inch||59.0 inch|
|Shoulder room, 2nd row||61.7 inch||57.8 inch|
|Shoulder room, 3rd row||57.3 inch||55.0 inch|
|EPA passenger volume||157.3 cu. pi.||141.3 cu.|
|EPA cargo volume||97.6 cu. pi.||84.3 cu. pi.|